4131 Fixed _best_ - Abu Dawood

(Note: The full, detailed exchange regarding these prohibitions and the mention of Al-Hasan ibn Ali can be found in the referenced documents). Sunnah.com Summary of Prohibitions Mentioned

It is important to note that the famous "muddy spring" story is actually found in the Tafsir literature regarding Surah Al-Kahf (18:86) and is also narrated in Sahih Al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim , not primarily Abi Dawud 4131. However, Abi Dawud 4131 is often conflated with these narrations because they share the theme of the sun prostrating beneath the Throne. abu dawood 4131 fixed

: Some versions (USC-MSA English) link this number to a report by Jabir ibn Samurah , who saw the Prophet (ﷺ) reclining on a pillow on his left side. : Some versions (USC-MSA English) link this number

: Deeply offended by this disrespect toward the Prophet's family, al-Miqdam vowed that he would not leave that day until he had confronted Muawiyah with truths he might find "disagreeable". The Interrogation of Principles (Note: The full

In Hadith terminology, when someone asks if a narration is "fixed," they are often checking its authenticity (Isnad) Sahih Status: This specific narration is graded as Sahih (Authentic) by prominent modern scholar

(If you want the exact Arabic text and literal translation, tell me which edition or provide the Arabic; I will include the precise wording.)

The narration is often cited as an example of companions practicing Nasiha (sincere advice) and confronting leaders when they deviate from established Sunnah.